{
  "pairId": "grinnell-usgs-1910-2016",
  "title": "Grinnell Glacier: a documented 1910 and 2016 comparison",
  "checkedDate": "2026-10-24",
  "sourceTitle": "USGS: Grinnell, Gem & Salamander Glaciers in 1910 and 2016",
  "sourceUrl": "https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/grinnell-gem-salamander-glaciers-1910-and-2016",
  "sourceImageUrl": "https://d9-wret.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/production/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/11_Grinnell%20ridge.jpg",
  "sourceFilename": "then-now-grinnell-source.jpg",
  "sourceSha256": "6ee77378c4cb7b474d6e0b387b0c975b198b987bde2aa3b0e8f4530a6eaa7bc7",
  "sourceWidth": 1260,
  "sourceHeight": 1697,
  "rightsUrl": "https://www.usgs.gov/information-policies-and-instructions/copyrights-and-credits",
  "rightsNote": "This specific USGS item is marked Public Domain. USGS policy describes U.S. public-domain use and requires separate attention to marked third-party material; no blanket global legal clearance or endorsement is claimed.",
  "movie": {"name":"then-now-grinnell-demo","seconds":30,"width":1080,"height":1920,"fps":24,"comparisonHoldSeconds":20,"creditHoldSeconds":10,"audio":"none"},
  "limits": "This is a dated historical comparison, not a 2026 photograph. Exact camera coordinates, lens and registration are not supplied here. Snow conditions, season, framing and photographic process differ. Do not infer a numerical change rate or a complete cause from two pictures. The original stacked composite, its date labels and credits remain intact.",
  "logRows": [
    {"field":"pair_id","label":"Pair ID","older":"grinnell-usgs-1910-2016 / upper panel","recent":"grinnell-usgs-1910-2016 / lower panel"},
    {"field":"place","label":"Place","older":"Grinnell Glacier basin, Glacier National Park","recent":"Same named basin in the USGS repeat-photo composite"},
    {"field":"capture_date_and_uncertainty","label":"Capture date","older":"1910; USGS item states 8/9/1910 (source wording retained)","recent":"2016; USGS item states 9/27/2016 (source wording retained)"},
    {"field":"creator_and_title","label":"Creator / title","older":"M. Elrod, U of M Library; upper image of the USGS Grinnell, Gem & Salamander comparison","recent":"L. McKeon, USGS; lower image of the same comparison"},
    {"field":"item_record_url","label":"Item record","older":"https://www.usgs.gov/media/images/grinnell-gem-salamander-glaciers-1910-and-2016","recent":"Same specific item record; two photographs within one supplied composite"},
    {"field":"rights_and_permission_record","label":"Reuse record","older":"Specific USGS item marked Public Domain; reviewed 24 October 2026 with USGS Copyrights and Credits policy","recent":"Same item-level designation; no blanket claim about every government-hosted image"},
    {"field":"viewpoint","label":"Viewpoint","older":"Across the basin toward the banded rock wall; exact coordinates, lens and camera height not supplied","recent":"Similar basin-facing view; framing differs and is not pixel-registered"},
    {"field":"matching_landmarks","label":"Fixed landmarks","older":"Central stepped/banded rock wall and the high ridge/right-hand cliff profile","recent":"The same rock formations are visible; compare the full frames rather than a misleading wipe"},
    {"field":"season_and_other_limits","label":"Other limits","older":"Different capture date and photographic process; snow and visibility are not controlled here","recent":"Colour view from a different date; these pictures alone do not quantify a change rate"},
    {"field":"alterations","label":"Alterations","older":"No crop, colourisation, reconstruction or removal of the source labels; supplied composite retained","recent":"Same; only whole-image fitting in the teaching video and cover"},
    {"field":"source_filename","label":"Source file","older":"then-now-grinnell-source.jpg, upper panel; supplied file is one two-photo composite","recent":"then-now-grinnell-source.jpg, lower panel; same byte-identical composite"},
    {"field":"public_credit","label":"Public credit","older":"1910: M. Elrod, U of M Library. Source: U.S. Geological Survey.","recent":"2016: L. McKeon, USGS. Source: U.S. Geological Survey."},
    {"field":"review_decision","label":"Decision","older":"Use this exact credited composite for the dated teaching example; retain the source record and limits","recent":"Use with an explicit 2016 label; do not describe it as today's or a 2026 view"}
  ]
}
